LQ Reputation System

dugan · 03-26-2011, 06:59 PM

Did "Did you find this post helpful?" suddenly stop adding rep? Usually, you can't give reputation to the same post twice, which means you can't both give reputation for a post and mark it helpful. Well, I was just able to rate this post helpful and give rep positive rep (along with a comment) for it. The poster's reputation record now shows only the reputation I added. It does not show the positive rep that should have been added when I rated it helpful.

MTK358 · 03-26-2011, 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dugan

Did "Did you find this post helpful?" suddenly stop adding rep? Usually, you can't give reputation to the same post twice, which means you can't both give reputation for a post and mark it helpful. Well, I was just able to rate this post helpful and give rep positive rep (along with a comment) for it. The poster's reputation record now shows only the reputation I added. It does not show the positive rep that should have been added when I rated it helpful.

I noticed that if you click "Add Rep" and Post Helpful" in a certain order, the forum allows it, and otherwise it doesn't. I don't remember the order, though.

corp769 · 03-27-2011, 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MTK358

I noticed that if you click "Add Rep" and Post Helpful" in a certain order, the forum allows it, and otherwise it doesn't. I don't remember the order, though.

You add rep, then find the post helpful

MTK358 · 03-27-2011, 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corp769

You add rep, then find the post helpful

OK, I remember now. There were a few instances where I marked a post as helpful, then thought it deserves more than that, but then it wouldn't let me add rep.

corp769 · 03-27-2011, 01:05 PM

Yeah I do that a lot. Honestly, I think that clicking "Yes" should give the same amount of rep as when you give a user actual rep.

TobiSGD · 03-27-2011, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corp769

Yeah I do that a lot. Honestly, I think that clicking "Yes" should give the same amount of rep as when you give a user actual rep.

I think, that there should be a difference betweeen clicking on "Yes" and giving reputation.
For example there are posts that are short, but help the OP to get his problem solved. In this case I would click on "Yes". But if it is a well-written post with a good and complete explanation, I think it deserves more reputation. In that case I give reputation with the reputation-symbol.

EricTRA · 03-27-2011, 01:31 PM

Hi,

I completely agree with TobiSGD, there should indeed be a difference. A lot of posts are just short and although they might point into the right direction to help the OP, they don't clarify what needs to be done in order to solve the problem at hand. On the other hand there are post by more 'seasoned' members that clarify each step and/or part of a command so that the OP learns from the post itself without having to Google or read man pages to understand a solution given. Those types of post merit more reputation in my opinion too for being informative, educational, complete and helpful.

Kind regards,

Eric

PS: there not only should be a difference, there is a difference. Clicking helpful only ups one rep while using the reputation icon reps a percentage of the reputation of the one giving the rep if I recall correct.

greencedar · 01-23-2019, 05:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeremy

Based on this thread I think it's clear that some kind of reputation system would be extremely beneficial to LQ. It will help members gauge the potential validity of answers from members they do not personally know and will also help members better understand how helpful they are to other LQ members. With this in mind I'd like to outline some of the rules, features and potential pitfalls I potentially see in such a system. This will allow for proper discussion to happen before such a system is enabled.

* Any member (except for mods and admins) will be able to opt out of the reputation system.
* Members in the "New Member" group will not be able to use the reputation system. Once a member makes a single post and is in the "Member" group, they will be able to leave positive reputation. A member in the "Senior Member" group or higher will be able to leave positive or negative reputation. All negative reputation will require a comment.
* A member will need to have a certain amount of reputation before they can give reputation and the amount of reputation you'll be able to give will depend on how much you get.
* There will be some kind of "spread" system, where $x amount of members will need to give a member reputation before the same member can use the system on the same member.
* How many days a member has been registered and number of posts will likely play a small role.
* There will likely be a tie-in with "Did you find this post helpful".
* Reputation will be displayed in your UserCP and in some way in individual posts.
* Phase 2 of the system will probably include some forum specific component, where you have an LQ-wide reputation which can be broken down by on a per forum basis.

I'd like some additional thought and feedback on this. From there we can look into rolling the system out and making additional tweaks. Thanks.

--jeremy

Thank you for this thread on the LQ Reputation System. I do not fully know how it works but I do have a better grasp of your system.

greencedar