Quote:
Originally Posted by Lady Fitzgerald
If one has to use the firmware or OS from the vendor to get hardware to work, that is the very definition of vendor lock-in.
|
Once again: the System76 Darter pro
is the Clevo N151CU, which incidentally also is the Entroware Proteus (Entroware is another company that sells laptops with Linux pre-installed).
Take a look at the links from my previous post.
They clearly show that it is possible to install other OSs on this laptop.
Being the only one providing a fully working system for your hardware, preinstalled, is not the definition of vendor lock-in.
I can see how it can feel like it for users that are not advanced enough to perform certain low-level system installations themselves. But then again, a misbehaving keyboard backlight is NOT the same as "not working".
You also have to keep in mind that this hardware is fairly new and Linux in general is still catching up with it, or some of its components. Give it another year, you'll see Linux Mint flying on the Clevo N151CU!
It seems to me that system76, by providing
completely FOSS firmware packages for it that can be installed on many OS besides Pop_OS, is rather ahead of the curve and by no means trying to lock its customers in, quite the opposite: it's doing the Linux community a favour because already now others are benefitting from their work.
Example (again, the very hardware OP uses).
Now if you or OP could show us that system76's firmware packages are designed to keep users using system76's own OSs, please do.
An explanation of
why system76 would do it (how they would gain from it) would also be appreciated.
All
I see is a bunch of freely available, opensource drivers/firmware etc. for top-notch brand new Clevo laptops:
https://github.com/pop-os?q=system76+driver
Written in good ol' C, GUI utilities in Python.
Completely transparent, GPL'd. What is there to complain about?
People install other OSs on their Clevo laptops (and apparently it doesn't matter one bit whether it has the original BIOS/UEFI or Coreboot):
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php...6_Darter_Pro_6
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/System76_Oryx_Pro
https://support.system76.com/articles/install-ubuntu/
PS: I said system76 are asking too much for their hardware, but an initial comparison says not so:
https://system76.com/laptops/darp6/configure
https://clevo-computer.com/it/laptop...-thunderbolt-3
Both around 1000USD depending on your setup.
PPS: you have to separate firmware and OS in your statement, which, it seems to me, neither of you is doing.
It is somewhat excusable in this case because system76 do offer firmware packages, but technically vague.
PPPS: Just now I see that even system76 offer their devices with Ubuntu preinstalled, as an alternative to Pop_OS.