Dear Slackware Developers,
I very much appreciate your work on Slackware. I would like to suggest an improvement on Slackware installer, or at least ask a question for clarification.
I just would like to ask question about the setup “Select Prompting Mode” step. The menu and the options have been changed, and I think the older version was better.
In an older version of Slackware Install the options and the explanations were these:
menu Choose groups of packages from interactive menus
expert Choose individual packages from interactive menus.
I’m referring to the old installer, please see on the Slackbook webpage 3.4.7:
On the other hand, the newer and current version of Installer says this:
menu Choose individual packages from interactive menus
expert This is actually the same as the “menu” option
I think the old version was better: it was more clear and it offered two genuinely different options: selection of groups of packages vs selections of individual packages. Why it has been changed?
Also, I think it would be better if the users had this option as well. Is it possible to, say, in next release of Slackware (15.0) we’ll get the old install options again with two different and clearly distinguishable options?
In sum, I think the current installer is either a bit confusing or redundant. Also, I don’t see at all an improvement here from the newer version.
I think there are two sensible options:
1. If there is currently no real difference between the “menu” and “expert” options, then there is no reason to keep both of them. I would suggest to keep only one of those with the explanation as follows: “Choose individual packages from interactive menus”.
2. If, however, there is or should be a real difference and choice between individual vs groups of packages, then the old version of installer should be used.
I would go for (2), the old version, since the explanation is clear, it offers an extra option and more flexibility in installing.
Thank you for clarification.