Linux - NewbieThis Linux forum is for members that are new to Linux.
Just starting out and have a question?
If it is not in the man pages or the how-to's this is the place!
Welcome to LinuxQuestions.org, a friendly and active Linux Community.
You are currently viewing LQ as a guest. By joining our community you will have the ability to post topics, receive our newsletter, use the advanced search, subscribe to threads and access many other special features. Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!
Note that registered members see fewer ads, and ContentLink is completely disabled once you log in.
I want to reinstall Windows. I have a second hard drive formatted in ext3 with mp3s I want to keep. Can Windows read ext3 partitions, or do I need to reformat to fat32 in order to transfer my files over?
I have a fat32 disk but there are a lot of downsides. No permissions on the files and often applications will give warnings or even errors about that. And there's a 4 gig per file size limit. Very annoying if you use it as a data disk and you use dvd isos or somesuch.
Originally posted by nx5000 Your link is the same tool but in version 0.3 and with GPL license and source code
The link I posted is version 1.10a! with read/write support but with license Freeware
It has the same function. But they are not the same project. The software at your link seems to have some security issues (everybody has full access). If that's not a problem than fine. Also, I prefer GPL to Freeware for obvious reasons.
Version numbers mean crap. Firefox 0.6 had features and was more secure then IE 6.*.
It provides Windows NT4.0/2000/XP/2003 with full access to Linux Ext2 volumes (read access and write access). This may be useful if you have installed both Windows and Linux as a dual boot environment on your computer.
One of the alternatives of having a partition can can be read/write by both Linux and XP/Vista is to use Ext2/3 partition and install Ext2ifs to the Windoze.
This arrangement overcomes the maximum 4Gb limitation of Fat32 and is used by many Linux users.
I use it myself and can certify it isn't read only.
The documentation of Ext2ifs says the file journalling of Ext3 is dropped and so the files are manipulated as Ext2. I would have thought it is a bit much to ask a OS foreign to Linux to guarantee the file integrity by maintaining the journalling mechanism. If I were M$ I wouldn't even have anything to do with Ext2ifs at all.
Don't know anything similar exist for Reiserfs or xfs filing systems.
* Access rights are not maintained. All users can access all the directories and files of an Ext2 volume. If a new file or directory is created, it inherits all the permissions, the GID and the UID from the directory where it has been created. With version 1.10a of the software there is one exception to this rule: a file (but not a directory) the driver has created always has cleared "x" permissions, it inherits the "r" and the "w" permissions only. See also section "What limitations arise from not maintaining access rights?".
* The driver treats files which have got a file name beginning with a dot "." character like other files, but not as hidden files.
* The driver does not allow accessing special files at Ext2 volumes, the access will be always denied. (Special files are sockets, soft links, block devices, character devices and pipes.)
* Neither different code pages nor UTF-8 encoded file names are supported. The driver always uses the current code page of Windows.
* Alternate 8.3-DOS names are not supported (just because there is no place to store them in an Ext2 file system). This can prevent legacy DOS applications, executed by the NTVDM of Windows, from accessing some files or directories.
* Currently the driver does not implement defragging support. So defragmentation applications will neither show fragmentation information nor defragment any Ext2 volume.
* This software does not achieve booting a Windows operating system from an Ext2 volume.
* LVM volumes are not supported, so it is not possible to access them.
The first caused me a lot of trouble, all suid bits were lost after several operations from windows.
For accessing other FS, I used qemu. kqemu is GPL since a few days.