System won't shut down fully on Intel Desktop Board

Hello,
I'm having a problem with shutting down my PC.
Hardware specs:
CPU Intel Core 2 Duo E8200
Intel Desktop Board DG33TL
3 GB RAM, 160 GB HDD, 350W PSU...
___________
If I wanna shut down my computer, then it'll hang on shutting down screen, fans are still running, but HDD will power off. If I'll suspend my PC to RAM and then wake up it, it won't power on my HDD correctly and it freezes.
___________
What I have tried:
1.) reinstalling my distro - I have tried Debian Stretch and Jessie, Ubuntu Trusty, Fedora 26
2.) updating BIOS to last version - this solved my problem for 1 week
3.) disabling UEFI boot
4.) forcing ACPI in GRUB
5.) shutting down with SysRq key and combination of another keys as is explained here https://askubuntu.com/questions/5080...ck-on-shutdown
___________
I don't have any problem with shutting down while I use Microsoft Windows. I think there is a problem with ACPI, but I don't know where.

Thanks to all who will help me with this problem.
Best regards,
mikou.

Tell us what happens when you try each of these commands
1. sudo shutdown -h now #It should power off
2. sudo shutdown -r now #it should reboot
3. echo mem > /sys/power/state #it should suspend to memory. Disk should stop
4. echo disk > /sys/power/state # It should hibernate to disk.

It sounds like you are dualbooting here. Did you make sure to turn off "Fast StartUp"
on Windows? If not, when "shutting down" Windows, it is actually being put into a hibernation and suspended to disk. If you boot linux while Windows is suspended, it can cause all kinds of issues. I would check on this first if you have not already

What used to be:

# shutdown -h now

Is now, thanks to systemd:

# shutdown -H -P +0

YMMV depending on your distro. Although acpi-support still has /etc/acpi/powerbtn-acpi-support.sh using:

# shutdown -h -P now

in debian stretch.

I had a distro do that on a server for a while till a kernel update. Guess you could rule out Debian by trying other distro's. Flash drive install should be OK to test. If Debian usb flash drive works correctly then that may lead to issue. I assume it is stopping too fast.

Originally Posted by business_kid Tell us what happens when you try each of these commands 1. sudo shutdown -h now #It should power off 2. sudo shutdown -r now #it should reboot 3. echo mem > /sys/power/state #it should suspend to memory. Disk should stop 4. echo disk > /sys/power/state # It should hibernate to disk.

It didn't power off, however, rebooting is not problem. If I suspend it with that command, it froze while I wanted to wake up it, so it's same like powering off/rebooting/suspending from dialog in XFCE (xfce4-logout).

Originally Posted by TheEzekielProject It sounds like you are dualbooting here. Did you make sure to turn off "Fast StartUp" on Windows? If not, when "shutting down" Windows, it is actually being put into a hibernation and suspended to disk. If you boot linux while Windows is suspended, it can cause all kinds of issues. I would check on this first if you have not already

I don't have dualboot, only one system is installed on my HDD. I tried to use Microsoft Windows with different HDD. However, thanks for your advice, it might be good solution.

Originally Posted by Shadow_7 What used to be: # shutdown -h now Is now, thanks to systemd: # shutdown -H -P +0 YMMV depending on your distro. Although acpi-support still has /etc/acpi/powerbtn-acpi-support.sh using: # shutdown -h -P now in debian stretch.

Thanks for your advice, but it still freezes.

Originally Posted by jefro I had a distro do that on a server for a while till a kernel update. Guess you could rule out Debian by trying other distro's. Flash drive install should be OK to test. If Debian usb flash drive works correctly then that may lead to issue. I assume it is stopping too fast.

I also tried other distributions (Ubuntu, Fedora) and different HDDs. This problem happened also when I used Live CD.

Do you have the latest BIOS update for your board?

EDIT: My bad. I missed that. I swear I read that 4 times haha

If other not related distro's do this then you have a problem. I guess you could look at bios for any settings that might affect this. Setting it all to factory or default may help. There are some acpi settings usually. I guess you could run memtest for a day just to see if that is hanging up. I get the feeling the power drops too fast in part of it. Maybe try different psu?

mikou,

One possible solution:
https://askubuntu.com/questions/7626...-shutting-down

Alternatively try:
https://askubuntu.com/questions/7645...utdown-restart

Edit /etc/default/grub line:

GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT="quiet splash"

to

GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT="quiet splash acpi=force"

Run:

update-grub

Is this NEW hardware?

The acpi=force is a good option. I have that plus acpi_backlight=vendor so I can fiddle with the backlight on my "new" laptop. Without those I have no control over the backlight and it's super bright by default. Well, limited control while running X I can use xrandr and --off to shut off the LCD. Looks a bit like this in the actual grub.cfg:

linux   /boot/vmlinuz-4.11.0-1-amd64 root=UUID=11111111-1111-1111-1111-111111111111 ro  quiet acpi=force acpi_backlight=vendor

Several other kernel parms that might help deal with it. If it's a very OLD machine then acpi=false might help since it might use APM. Although you might need a new kernel to enable those options depending on distro.

Originally Posted by mikou It didn't power off, however, rebooting is not problem. If I suspend it with that command, it froze while I wanted to wake up it, so it's same like powering off/rebooting/suspending from dialog in XFCE (xfce4-logout).

Please give us a numbered reaction with what stops and what doesn't. Also the systemd command should be used (shutdown -H -P +0 or shutdown -h -P now depending on your distro)

I've had more than one machine that simply halted instead of turning off. I had to press the power button to actually turn off the machine.