Why can't X in Linux look more like XP or better.. serious question
Linux - GeneralThis Linux forum is for general Linux questions and discussion.
If it is Linux Related and doesn't seem to fit in any other forum then this is the place.
Notices
Welcome to LinuxQuestions.org, a friendly and active Linux Community.
You are currently viewing LQ as a guest. By joining our community you will have the ability to post topics, receive our newsletter, use the advanced search, subscribe to threads and access many other special features. Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!
Note that registered members see fewer ads, and ContentLink is completely disabled once you log in.
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us. If you need to reset your password, click here.
Having a problem logging in? Please visit this page to clear all LQ-related cookies.
Get a virtual cloud desktop with the Linux distro that you want in less than five minutes with Shells! With over 10 pre-installed distros to choose from, the worry-free installation life is here! Whether you are a digital nomad or just looking for flexibility, Shells can put your Linux machine on the device that you want to use.
Exclusive for LQ members, get up to 45% off per month. Click here for more info.
and so im also just wondering if anyone else feels the same way and perhaps wants to do something about it? even in simple ways or in the future and we can see what happens go from there anyways leave a post or email me if you wish
Originally posted by dmx9595 no buddy im not trying to force anyone to use linux of course, but im telling people about linux and there open too it is what im saying but in reality i dont tell them where u can get it etc.. because i know they will not know how to use it cause it is not easy enough for them, thats what i meant..
That's exactly what I do, too. When friends complain to me about the problems they're having with their Windows machines, I tell them why I use Linux but I don't try to get them to go to Linux, because I know how tough it was for me and I know they almost surely would just be disappointed. Too bad, too.
Oh right, I understand now and pretty much agree with you, while I have friends with problems with their windows machines I will tell them why I use Linux whilst trying to fix them and also if I show anyone on my computer something and they are confused as to why the desktop lokks like it does I will explain to them that its Linux, but I haven't the time to actively promote linux, but many of my friends know about linux by seeing my computer and if any decide to try it I will definately help them in getting started and point them to tutorials/forums on the internet
yeah its just a shame the general public cant use linux and its not linux's fault either but yes this what I hope to change in my lifetime even if it is just at worst some minor changes though hopefully i will also find others who want to be of some use and accomplish the same thing
Originally posted by dmx9595 ... this what I hope to change in my lifetime even if it is just at worst some minor changes ...
Good for you! The old saying, "A journey of a thousand miles begins with one step" is true! (Commonly ascribed to Lin Yutang, but I'll bet it goes way back in history.)
You kind of made my day with your good attitude. Thanks.
I am very much for Linux and use it probably 96% of the time...But
Windows is just so crisp, I mean the quality of text and such on Firefox for Windows compaired to current Firefox on Linux is no compair. The quality of objects on the screen is reall anoying Im running Fedora code 2 which I know isnt the most 'Eye checking of all' but most of the text on the screen is kinda squshed together more or less, I cant really explain what I mean but I wish that at least Fedora had a crisper sharper look.
Re: Why can't X in Linux look more like XP or better.. serious question
Quote:
Originally posted by dmx9595
Hey.. Im not even new to linux at all but Im curious and wanting to help make linux more user friendly so that all the people out there who dont know how to use a computer but do use windows could also use linux instead..
If you want to help people to begin to use Linux, hand them a LiveCD and let them try it out themselves. They might careless what the desktop enviroment looks like as long as they are able to get work/task done sufficiently.
Quote:
now of course theres distros like mandrake n such that make it easier which is good but thats not enough..
I think that has more to do with the desktop enviroment the distro is using, then the distro itself.
Quote:
and so I was just pondering why is linux's display manager like gtk n what not not near as preety as windows,
Who said Windows was pretty? I feel that the fisher-price look of XP is horrible. It hurts my eyes looking at it. And the look of 2K is bland and boring IMHO. Its all a matter of opinion. What is "pretty" to you may very well not be eye-pleasing or sufficient for others.
Quote:
or what stops it from looking better in X windows system? is it simply choice or lack of developers or no one has bothered to make a better display or one isnt wanted at this time or?
There are tons of DE's and window managers for use in GNU/Linux. Each one caters to the different tastes that people have. Have you tried them all? Are you willing to code one if you can't find one to meet your needs?
Speaking of XP's desktop enviroment, if you miss it or prefer it, then you can use XPDE as your Linux DE to get that XP "look". Personally I would never install that "thing" on my GNU/Linux system, but thats just me.
nice thanks for that xpde link a lot, yeah of course i wouldnt use this nor you but someone who has never heard of linux this will make it easier for them to migrate
easy to lose sight of the fact that most people have a comp to do stuff with not too!
used to spend a lot of time under the bonnet of cars but for most people they are interesting because they work not because of how they work
the curse of open source is the atitude that if people dont want to put a couple of hundred hours in learning they in some way dont deserve the benifits
on top of that you have to add that for the av user mistakes are expensive time consuming and somewhat embarasing(not unlike my spelling)
how many of you would have learnt to drive a car if you had to prove you could rebuild the engine before you were allowed behind the wheel?
just a thought
yeah i know about superkaramba and how you can make the desktop look i know aobut all that i think it just spilled my mind or something and i guess i was talking more about the default doesnt look good to me, i just found these live cd scripts that are made so you can make your own live cd out of your own made distro so this looks really intresting im gonna try this out i could just take knoppix try and mess with it a bit maybe put in XPde customizie the desktop so its real simple but splash screens n stuff instead of kernel messages and perhaps it would be good enough to burn it and pass it to some people
thanks for the links guys again.
The reason is probably because of the fact the developers who made said programs are satisfied by the way they look.
You see, Linux developers don't really care of Linux becomes the #1 OS in the world or not. They don't care. All they care about is that they use it and enjoy it, and that's that.
All you should care about is that you enjoy using Linux, and not how large of the world uses it too.
I would say, if you want something to be different, develop your own DE and application suite, and please GPL it so it can be improved, otherwise don't complain.
However, I understand your concern. It's just that the developers who develop these things don't really mind if it's #1 software or not.
They do what they love to do, program, and they're doing it.
Im new to linux still and i absolutely love the look of X, especially kde, it blows away windows by a major landslide i think. On windows i used to use apps like windowblinds and stuff to skin the gui but at the same time those apps sucked my memory like a porno star sucking ****. And from what Ive seen, people who are not familuar with linux are totally blown away when they see the linux desktop for the first time
LinuxQuestions.org is looking for people interested in writing
Editorials, Articles, Reviews, and more. If you'd like to contribute
content, let us know.