*BSDThis forum is for the discussion of all BSD variants.
FreeBSD, OpenBSD, NetBSD, etc.
Notices
Welcome to LinuxQuestions.org, a friendly and active Linux Community.
You are currently viewing LQ as a guest. By joining our community you will have the ability to post topics, receive our newsletter, use the advanced search, subscribe to threads and access many other special features. Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!
Note that registered members see fewer ads, and ContentLink is completely disabled once you log in.
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us. If you need to reset your password, click here.
Having a problem logging in? Please visit this page to clear all LQ-related cookies.
Get a virtual cloud desktop with the Linux distro that you want in less than five minutes with Shells! With over 10 pre-installed distros to choose from, the worry-free installation life is here! Whether you are a digital nomad or just looking for flexibility, Shells can put your Linux machine on the device that you want to use.
Exclusive for LQ members, get up to 45% off per month. Click here for more info.
With all honesty, I've been interested in learning *BSDs since the day I started using Slackware regularly, however every time I place my eye on some informative *BSD thread in any *BSD forum, it always, without fail, contains some pretty weird anti-Linux statements like
'Linux sucks because BSD doesn't', 'This is not Linux you n00b, RTFM', 'Go keep using Linux because BSD is not for you', 'Look at the man pages of Linux, they stink', 'LVM sucks', 'Linux screwed the UNIX way of working, it's complex' etc.
And it doesn't really feel nice always.
I don't mean to be a troll here, I'm too busy for that, but these type of posts especially from some senior and technical members(not all) of the *BSD communities around kinda hamper the *nix spirit and demotivate a learning newbie.
No wonder, Steve Jobs did give a r@t'$ a$$ to *BSD community's ideology while using (parts of)BSD as the base, simply closing the source.
@PrinceCruise: I also find various incomprehensible or unjustified anti-Linux comments that crop up from time to time to be pointless and off putting. However, you do find similar types of anti-Windows and anti-Mac comments on various Linux forums as well (including LQ).
I wish the Linux and FreeBSD communities would avoid the childish, mocking put downs of rival OSes and focus only on their own unique strengths, but I realise that humans natural tribalism means that this will never fully happen. My advice to your would therefore be to go ahead try one of the BSDs anyway, if they interest you. Just ignore this comments you don't like.
Here a few quick things that appeal to me about FreeBSD (and the same probably holds true for the other BSDs but I have no real experience). I will compare to a three Linux distributions that people here have mentioned as being similar but try to give more concrete examples of differences that you might like.
They provide and maintain versioned releases, unlike ArchLinux and Gentoo which are rolling
They have a massive selection of binary packages and ports, unlike the relatively small Slackware repository (even taking into account SBo, which is still pretty small in comparison)
They have very thorough documentation in a consistent format that is available even when you don't have an internet connection (sometimes the case during install). The Arch and Gentoo Wikis are great if you have an internet connection. Slackware's Slackbook is currently not as well maintained.
They have a simple and easy to understand init system, unlike Gentoo
@ruario - Thanks for a good write up. I totally understand the niche of *BSDs and more than willing to start learning some or more.
I've in fact learnt to ignore(the hard way) the unnecessary and irrelevant comments about personal preferences on any forum. To each his own.
I totally understand the niche of *BSDs and more than willing to start learning some or more.
I think learning a BSD is an excellent way to stretch yourself and gain new perspectives. You're a Slacker so learning a BSD will be a cake walk for you. I would recommend installing FreeBSD into a VM (maybe use virtualbox). It is an enjoyable experience.
I don't mean to be a troll here, I'm too busy for that, but these type of posts especially from some senior and technical members(not all) of the *BSD communities around kinda hamper the *nix spirit and demotivate a learning newbie.
Just take it all with a pinch of salt. I think overall the *nix community has a common goal but the various branches take their own path so differences, between those taking the various routes, will happen. Of course there will be the purists who likes one BSD derivative or Linux distro and good for them - they tend to defend their patch, just like you would if you're a petrol head and you like Fords or GM etc...
I think that trying FreeBSD may be a nice learning experience and I still have to try it (in a serious way), but I would rather ask here for help if I try it than in their forum with that ridiculous moderator that seems to have nothing more to do than to sit in front of the computer searching for spelling/grammar errors in the posts the whole day. I couldn't stand that more than a few minutes. People are posting in those forums to get help with FreeBSD, not with the English language. Worse, if he thinks the people asking are to dumb for FreeBSD he points them to PC-BSD and closes their threads.
That is exactly not the way I want to be treated by a community and they really should consider if it is a good idea to push people away from their OS. It is not that they have a vast amount of users (or may be potential developers), so IMHO such a behavior from a forum moderator is one thing that shouldn't be tolerated.
Many people think that Slackware users behave elitist. They should have a look at FreeBSD.
I think that trying FreeBSD may be a nice learning experience and I still have to try it (in a serious way), but I would rather ask here for help if I try it than in their forum with that ridiculous moderator that seems to have nothing more to do than to sit in front of the computer searching for spelling/grammar errors in the posts the whole day. I couldn't stand that more than a few minutes. People are posting in those forums to get help with FreeBSD, not with the English language. Worse, if he thinks the people asking are to dumb for FreeBSD he points them to PC-BSD and closes their threads.
That is exactly not the way I want to be treated by a community and they really should consider if it is a good idea to push people away from their OS. It is not that they have a vast amount of users (or may be potential developers), so IMHO such a behavior from a forum moderator is one thing that shouldn't be tolerated.
Many people think that Slackware users behave elitist. They should have a look at FreeBSD.
Yeah....without naming names I do know which moderator that you are talking about. There are also some very knowledgeable people on that forum as well. It will be my pleasure to help you with FreeBSD if I can. The FreeBSD Hand Book is an exceptional document, much like the Slackbook. The newest version of FreeBSD has a revamped installer and is quite straight forward.
There is always DaemonForums, which covers all BSD's, if you don't like FreeBSD Forums. I actually think FreeBSD Forums are great as there are some very knowledgeable dudes on there. True, the moderator(s) on that forum don't take any sh*t but thats why it's so highly rated by it's users.
I actually think FreeBSD Forums are great as there are some very knowledgeable dudes on there. True, the moderator(s) on that forum don't take any sh*t but thats why it's so highly rated by it's users.
No argument from me. The FreeBSD Forums are first rate; I go there every day. I was thrilled when we got an official FreeBSD forum in 2008, I've been running FreeBSD since 5.x. I like 99.999 % of that forum. There is a bit of over moderation happening.
With all honesty, I've been interested in learning *BSDs since the day I started using Slackware regularly, however every time I place my eye on some informative *BSD thread in any *BSD forum, it always, without fail, contains some pretty weird anti-Linux statements like 'Linux sucks because BSD doesn't', 'This is not Linux you n00b, RTFM', 'Go keep using Linux because BSD is not for you', 'Look at the man pages of Linux, they stink', 'LVM sucks', 'Linux screwed the UNIX way of working, it's complex' etc. And it doesn't really feel nice always.
This is most certainly not true of the NetBSD mailing lists.
@TobiSGD So you are saying that you think this is excessive or that a quick Google search shows me that this moderator has edited tens of thousands of posts?
Last edited by ruario; 06-05-2012 at 03:46 AM.
Reason: added link to Google
LinuxQuestions.org is looking for people interested in writing
Editorials, Articles, Reviews, and more. If you'd like to contribute
content, let us know.