Compile error, 'H5G_obj_t' does not name a type, is gcc 4.3 incompatible with gcc 3 ?

samrat_rao · 03-01-2009, 03:30 AM

Hi,
I am trying to compile a package hdf-1.6.8 for openSUSE 11.0. But i think there is a problem when gcc 4.3 is used. The make fails giving errors like:

Quote:

In file included from H5IdComponent.cpp:21:
H5IdComponent.h:86: error: 'H5G_obj_t' does not name a type

The header file has such entries:

Code:

H5G_obj_t p_get_refobj_type(void *ref, H5R_type_t ref_type) const;

Is this a cause for conflicts between gcc 3 and gcc 4. If so how do i rectify the same? I have compat-ltdc++ installed. Similar errors are sure to follow during the compilation process.

knudfl · 03-01-2009, 12:10 PM

HDF5 1.6.8 software > > hdf5-1.6.8.tar.gz from
ftp://ftp.hdfgroup.org/HDF5/current16/src/

'cd hg5-1.6.8', './configure', 'make' runs with no errors
on a clean install of Suse 11.0,
using gcc43-4.3.1_20080507-6.1 .

There is a 'compat-libstdc++' for Suse 11.0, but it isn't
used, as all code in HG5 is c-code, no c++.
And there is no compiler connected to 'compat-libstdc++'.

There is no gcc-3 for Suse 11.0, unless you installed an
alternative one yourself.
I do not see, how you can talk about a gcc3, gcc4 conflict,
unless you are using some special configure options.

The only possible reason for an error I can think of, is if
you have another version of gcc-4.3 .? ?
.....

samrat_rao · 03-01-2009, 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by knudfl

And there is no compiler connected to 'compat-libstdc++'.

What does this mean?

Quote:

There is no gcc-3 for Suse 11.0, unless you installed an alternative one yourself.

No i haven't installed gcc 3. I learnt that it is too troublesome and will cause dependency kinda problems with gcc 4. I have the gcc that you mentioned for openSUSE 11.0.

Quote:

I do not see, how you can talk about a gcc3, gcc4 conflict, unless you are using some special configure options.

I used the configure option:

Code:

--enable-cxx

I do not have a gcc conflict. I was just wondering if hdf5-1.6.8 is better off being compiled with gcc 3 as i did not have problems compiling hdf5-1.8.2.

knudfl · 03-02-2009, 07:57 AM

Please try this : 'cd hg5-1.6.8' .. 'make distclean'
( or unpack hg5-1.6.8/ to a new location in /home/<username>/ )

And next rerun './configure' with no options.

( --enable-cxx is not a usable option, AFAIK, see './configure --help' .
.... And what was the --enable-cxx meant to do ? ? )

As already said, running make should work on Suse 11 with no errors.
.....

samrat_rao · 03-03-2009, 10:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by knudfl

( --enable-cxx is not a usable option, AFAIK, see './configure --help' .
.... And what was the --enable-cxx meant to do ? ? )......

But typing ./configure --help gives an option --enable-cxx which is: Compile the C++ interface [default=no]

Why is it not usable?

And yes, a simple ./configure, make, make check is a success. But why not with --enable-cxx?

knudfl · 03-03-2009, 02:28 PM

I am very sorry, must have been sleepy ?
Now I found both the c++ code and the option --enable-cxx .
( And the --enable-fortran = 'Compile the fortran interface' too ! )

'./configure --enable-cxx' :
Works OK with 'g++-4.3' here, make sure, that 'gcc-c++' is installed,
and that 'g++' is present in /usr/bin/ .

This also works : './configure --enable-cxx CXX=g++34' :

I used the 'compat-gcc-34-c++-3.4.6-9.i386.rpm'
and 'compat-gcc-34-.4.6-9.i386.rpm' from Fedora 10.
http://download.fedora.redhat.com/pu...6/os/Packages/

( Fedora 10 has an equal 'glibc' and almost the same 'binutils'
as Suse 11, so the compiler works with no errors.)
:
The result in the hidden c++/.libs/ folder is 'libhdf5_cpp.a'
.....