Share your knowledge at the LQ Wiki.
Go Back > Reviews > Distributions > Mageia
User Name


Search · Register · Submit New Review · Download your favorite Linux Distributions ·

mageia 2
Reviews Views Date of last review
3 13027 06-08-2012
Recommended By Average Price Average Rating
No recommendations None indicated 5.0

Description: Originally forked from Mandriva; Mageia is a GNU/Linux-based, Free Software operating system. It is a community project, supported by a nonprofit organisation of elected contributors. the mission to build great tools for people.
Further than just delivering a secure, stable and sustainable operating system, the goal is to set up a stable and trustable governance to direct collaborative projects.
Keywords: mandriva-based

Post A Reply 
Old 06-02-2012, 04:48 AM   #1
Registered: Jul 2006
Distribution: CentOS, Salix
Posts: 4,754

Rep: Reputation:
Would you recommend the product? no | Price you paid?: None indicated | Rating: 6

Pros: Not bad
Cons: but the competition is better

Mageia has several disks available: live CDs for KDE and Gnome, an installation CD for LXDE, and an installation DVD for all three. I tested the 32-bit DVD. The site documentation is good and the installer easy to use, with pop-up help available. It offers various configurations, and to start with I chose the default KDE desktop. Encryption was not offered.

KDE was implemented with less clutter than in some distros, but it was still too slow on my hardware. I was able to make a considerable improvement by disabling Nepomuk: why was it running by default? The software included Firefox, Kmail, LibreOffice, Scribus, Gimp, Amarok, Totem, and Dragon player. When run from a terminal, Kmail, Scribus, and Amarok left serious warnings. The package manager has no help installed and was set up to use the DVD: you need to click on Options and Media manager, and then select six repositories.

Patented codecs are supposed to installable from the Tainted repository, but donít expect to find them by searching for ďcodecsĒ. In practice, mp3 files played. Videos were a different matter. Totem complained that the sound format wasnít supported and offered to download the codec. Even after that, neither Totem nor Dragon worked properly, but I had success installing VLC from the Tainted repository (thereís another VLC in Core without codecs!) Thereís a tool in the Configuration Centre that supposedly selected my USB speakers, but they only worked with Amarok: presumably itís configuring Phonon rather than ALSA.

I tried another installation, this time a custom one with the Ice window manager. It was confusing compared with a similar operation in CentOS or OpenSUSE, but it worked. I got a very minimal version of Ice (no file manager) and an odd selection of software: Firefox, Scribus, Homebank, Dia, Gimp, and an alpha-test version of the audio player Enjoy. So, why hadnít the default installation given me Dia or Homebank?

As a distro defaulting to KDE, Mageia invites comparison with Mepis and OpenSUSE. Both of these are better behaved and offer encryption. Mint and Salix are also easy, reliable distros offering KDE. Thatís four reasons for not using Mageia.
Old 06-02-2012, 10:04 PM   #2
Registered: Jan 2011
Distribution: OpenSUSE
Posts: 1,396

Rep: Reputation: Reputation:
Would you recommend the product? no | Price you paid?: None indicated | Rating: 5

Pros: I won't comment
Cons: Network manager!!!

I have been eager to give Mageia a go for some time. I held off until version 2 was released. I constantly read how happy people were with it. It sounded great.
My limited experience with Mandriva was when i was first beginning Gnu/Linux last year, and i could not get my mobile broadband to work with the network managing gui. Mageia has continued to use the same program for managing networks. I can still not obtain a connection. I decided to remove it and install network manager instead. I downloaded all the rpms needed and got it going. I was able to connect. I was using kde. Once a connection was established, something very odd occurred. I could no longer open any new windows. If a terminal had been left open from before establishing a connection, and then a program was lauched from that, it would fail with X errors. Once the connection was closed down, things would work again. I tried the gnome applet and the kde applet, and the issue continued to occur. It is a known bug that was reported in the betas, but was never fixed. I decided to remove network manage and instead comile it from source. No build tools are insalled by default, so i installed them, but then found that checkinstall was not in the repos. That was it for me. I had a horrible experience and would like to rate this lower, but since i did not get the chance to see how well the rest of the product works, i've given it a generous 5.
If you require network manager, don't try Mageia.
Old 06-08-2012, 06:26 AM   #3
Registered: Aug 2009
Distribution: Slackware64 -Current
Posts: 890

Rep: Reputation: Reputation: Reputation:
Would you recommend the product? no | Price you paid?: None indicated | Rating: 4

Pros: Kde looked differently good with their own add ons
Cons: Slow. Confusing package manager and Installer

I was really hoping for Mageia 2 to come out and had really high hopes with it but were shattered right after full installation.
I selected all the desktops and WM's and hoped full installation, still a lot of things went missing like kpp and virtualbox to name a few.
The package manager confuses you and still not implemented well. At least one repository could have been enabled right after by default rather than those annoying pop ups about missing media and all.
kde looks good but slows down everything else.
E17 installation was broken without any mention of how and why. PCmanFM never opened.
I don't want to crib anymore but I'm not going to suggest it to my Linux-newbie friends.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:06 AM.

Main Menu
Write for LQ is looking for people interested in writing Editorials, Articles, Reviews, and more. If you'd like to contribute content, let us know.
Main Menu
RSS1  Latest Threads
RSS1  LQ News
Twitter: @linuxquestions
Facebook: linuxquestions Google+: linuxquestions
Open Source Consulting | Domain Registration