Ubuntu 9.04 works out of the box on a Thinkpad, secondly why install a version that needs tinkering and that is to big and to modern for an old piece of hardware anyway.
You are right about to install Alsa, this is a more sensible thing to do anyway, purge the pulseaudio crap and use alsa and oss in compatible-mode, some games expect oss as backend.
Ubuntu made some wrong decisions in versions after 9.04 the evidence is the number of forums about not functioning hardware.
So my opinion was and reason to go back to 9.04 is;
1. It works out of the box, no tinkering required.
2. Stable, 9.04 is more stable and compatible on older hardware.
3. later versions use edev by default, you need to tamper xorg.conf (touchpad, DPMS, sleep issues).
And most important of all we don't want the daughter of S. to turn her back on Linux and turn her to the "Redmond Syndicate".