I recently posted a review for a distribution (1), and, when I clicked the "edit" link next to it, i was sent to (2), which gave a page identical to (1). I was able to figure out the problem, the right edit link would be (3)

(1)http://www.linuxquestions.org/reviews/showproduct.php/product/221/cpage/3/perpage/15/cat/24#poststart
(2)http://www.linuxquestions.org/reviews/showproduct.php/product/221/cpage/3/perpage/15/cat/reviews.php?product=221&cedit=1456
(3)http://www.linuxquestions.org/reviews/reviews.php?product=221&cedit=1456

Here is the question:
I did not find any similar threads, which brings me to ask why edit didn't work for me. (And still does not). I have no problem editing posts in forums.

Note: sorry for removing the links, but they were cut with "..."

how long ago did you post the review? I have a feeling that they need to
be approved before appearing, and thus you wouldn't be able to edit them,
if they had not appeared.

titanium_geek

That's only for submitting HCL products. Reviews are visible as soon as you post them. I was able to edit the review, my question is rather why the edit link did not work.

ahh, that's a bug then. try posting as much detail as possible-
that really helps jeremy when he is solving the problem.

titanium_geek

What details do you want?

I'll take a look into this. Thanks for the bug report.

--jeremy

Should be all set now.

--jeremy

Thanks! The 'edit' link now works fine.