-   Linux - Software (
-   -   Can't host server with firewall, but can with router, could use help please (

calimer 03-01-2005 06:08 PM

Can't host server with firewall, but can with router, could use help please
Well if you couldn't tell by the subject, I had a hard time figuring out what to put as the subject. Basically my question is, when I try to use my firewall to host a game server, no one can see it on the master server list but when I use my router, everyone can. I am opening up exactly both the same ports on my router and firewall, so I don't get why it will not work properly with the firewall. This also happens on windows too when I try to host a server of any game. The firewall seems to be way more restrictive than the router. I know I should probably have posted this in the games forum, but the question is a bit more general than that since I am trying to figure out what the key security and settings differences are between the firewall and router. I noticed that I can load up a lot more programs through my router without having to open ports than with the firewall, such as instant messaging. This seems a bit strange to me but I'm guessing that router has default ports already opened? I did do a test at to see if ports were open on my router and it said all were stealth, so I'm really just wondering what the story is behind all of this. Thanks for your time. Take care.

NoStop 03-01-2005 09:47 PM

You say you have a firewall in your router? Then why would you want another firewall between your computer and router?


calimer 03-01-2005 10:15 PM

It would be good to have some extra protection, though I know it is probably not needed. The main reason is because I really only use one main computer. I usually don't even have my router set up, except that I have it up now because I wanted to get the game server up and still be protected, since it wasn't working with the firewall. Also it is a matter of curosity as well. Take care.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:38 AM.