Remove proprietary codecs: What and How
Hi, I have tried many different Linux distros, and sometimes want to place them (like the LXDE) on older PCs to give away. However, most Linux flavors include proprietary multimedia codecs, which i understand in the US requires a license (and thus Flurendo sells the license for them. So i would like to simply remove the proprietary ones.
I know Linux Mint offers a version that does not have them by default, and it seems Fedora does not, and am not sure about any others, but i would like to any distro and just remove the proprietary codecs. Can someone give me a list of the file names, and where they would be? Thanks |
Well, I don't know about instructions that would work for every distro, but usually uninstalling a "restricted-extras" package will remove proprietary codecs.
|
Codecs are not installed by Fedora, OpenSUSE, or the special US version of Mint. There's not necessarily a simple way of removing them: I can't remember a distro that has a single "restricted" package (I try to forget my last experience of Arch!) and I've seen them called several different things. Frankly I'd say that no-one is going to come checking the computers for codecs and the patenting of them was only allowed by an ignorant judge misunderstanding the law anyway, as well as being stupid. But I tend to put my personal beliefs above the law: it's obviously up to you.
|
Quote:
|
on opensuse all of them are in the packman repo
see: http://en.opensuse.org/Restricted_formats just do not install that repo and you will never be able to watch any video other that ogg and will not be able to listen to anything other than flac there are some open codecs so some music and videos might be able to be watched this can be solved by uninstalling the multimedia players and not installing flash will stop them from watching swf vids in firefox but will not stop people from using html5 |
Quote:
In any case, if i just knew what codecs are at issue i could find them. |
Quote:
|
just use the normal standard install dvd's
the OS's with them HAVE PAID the licenses fees Conical PAID the "extortion fee" to the Mpeg licensing authority to use it Novell paid for some things in SELD so just use the normal everyday standard install dvd's |
Quote:
|
it really depends on what you are using
if for example you are using GStreammer some will be called the " gstreamer-(good , bad, ugly )" rpm's / deb's -- yes they are called "the good the bad and the ugly" "gstreamer-0_10-plugins-ffmpeg" or ffmpeg or mplayer -- you can use Xine or gstreamer OR the mplayer BUILT codecs ( can ONLY!! be used on mplayer) the 2011 ALL package http://www.mplayerhq.hu/MPlayer/rele...110131.tar.bz2 and that is only SOME of the video ONLY and not music |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
http://www.neowin.net/news/watching-...mostly-illegal It boils down to this: It's technically illegal, because there is no 'Linux Corporation' that makes EVERY version of Linux that paid the corporate extortion fee. Why on earth would it be ILLEGAL for you to watch a DVD that you LEGALLY PURCHASED AND OWN??? This would be as asinine as you not driving the car you purchased, because you didn't pay some third-party the fee that lets you open the door. If you are really that uptight about obeying a 'law' (and in this case, a law that was enacted due to stupidity and corporate pressure), then sell your old computers with NO operating system at all. Quote:
http://howto.cnet.com/8301-11310_39-...-in-windows-8/ Quote:
Please do some research on this. If you want to be 'legal', there is a $25 player for Linux that is...pat yourself on the back for paying money to a company for NO GOOD REASON. They DO NOT protect the artists or producers of content at all...the only people that benefit from this is the company that came up with this idea, and greased enough palms to get it enacted. |
There are two things at issue here.
1. The codecs for playing formats like mp3, mp4, etc. These are patented in the USA. Whether the law was actually intended to allow algorithms to be patented is very dubious, but under current case law in the USA you are expected to pay for them. But if you have any computer in your home that has a commercial OS, then you have paid; as I understand it, you only have to pay once. Companies trading in the US do not want to be sued for encouraging or aiding patent violation, so distros like OpenSUSE and Fedora do not supply codecs, and magazines do not put codecs in their cover disks. But no-one is going to make any money by suing a private individual, especially as they'd have to prove that the distro was supplied to someone who didn't have Windows or OSX. That's why other US distros do supply codecs. As I said, there is no standard way of naming them so you need knowledge of the distro to know how to remove them. This can be quite difficult: Mageia has two versions of ffmpeg, one supporting patented codecs and one not, but only distinguishable by the fact that they're in different repositories! Some distros have a file called w32codec, but neither of mine has. 2. The decoder for commercial DVDs is, I believe, illegal in the US under the DMCA unless purchased from a licensed supplier like Microsoft or Apple. That does have a standard name: libdvdcss. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
However, i am not looking to sell anything, but want to be legal myself, as well as give away that which is legal. Yet I am not defending unreasonable restrictions or a "nanny state" scenario, but I do want to be legal. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And thanks for your input. |
Quote:
|
If you want a distro without any proprietary stuff, try gNewSense:
http://www.gnewsense.org/ |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:36 AM. |