Hi,
Even though this thread is marked [Solved], I want to chime in here with my $.02
Over the years I have used many different manufacture drives from Seagate, WD, Toshiba just to name a few. I have failures from each of those. Environment will play a large contribution to the life of any spinning hardware. For a while Seagate was a leading drive that would have failures in my systems. I moved to WD & Toshiba with quality PSU and a good controlled environment. Temperatures and mechanical shock are the factors that must be addressed.
I started mounting with shock absorb mounts and adding a HDD fans for the bays. If you do not dress your cables properly then air flow across the drives can be limited/restricted. Placing screws in all the drive mounts helps heat transfer to the bay frames but using mechanical vibration absorb mounts materials can limit so one reason to use drive fans in the bays.
All my Laptops use a Lap Desk with cooling fans to help move the heat. Now that I am using SSD in most of my systems then HDD cooling and mechanical mounts are less. Most large HDD are external now so no more heat issues.
My advice for everyone is that every manufacture has potential for failure. For a while I would not buy Seagate because of personal history with HDD failures but when one does not address the problem areas like a quality PSU, heat transfer and proper handling of the HDD then any drive has the chance of failure.
Hope this helps.
Have fun & enjoy!