Finally got it sorted. Gparted on the Arch Linux System Rescue CD kept saying the backup GPT partition table was corrupted. Apparently clicking the option to fix it wasn't working.
So I thought, what if I change the partition map to something very unlike GPT? I chose Mac then created a new partition in the unallocated space. After applying that I changed it back to GPT and NTFS, then formatted it.
Finally! That has eliminated the 'ghost drive'. Could be that the live mode of that Ubuntu DVD doesn't properly support GPT NTFS over 2 TB and whatever it did to it while writing to it fouled up the partition table in some fashion to make Windows (and Debian Linux on Open Media Vault) see it as two separate drives.
So now I know, don't use a live Linux boot disk to write to an NTFS volume over 2 TB without first verifying that it can do it without screwing up the partition table of the destination drive.
I've named the drive Laz1 because it's been resurrected and it's Easter Sunday. I though about Hey-Soos but, nahhh. It's not that big of a deal.
