Read and Write to Ext3 Filesystem from Windows onto Linux
Linux - GeneralThis Linux forum is for general Linux questions and discussion.
If it is Linux Related and doesn't seem to fit in any other forum then this is the place.
Notices
Welcome to LinuxQuestions.org, a friendly and active Linux Community.
You are currently viewing LQ as a guest. By joining our community you will have the ability to post topics, receive our newsletter, use the advanced search, subscribe to threads and access many other special features. Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!
Note that registered members see fewer ads, and ContentLink is completely disabled once you log in.
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us. If you need to reset your password, click here.
Having a problem logging in? Please visit this page to clear all LQ-related cookies.
Get a virtual cloud desktop with the Linux distro that you want in less than five minutes with Shells! With over 10 pre-installed distros to choose from, the worry-free installation life is here! Whether you are a digital nomad or just looking for flexibility, Shells can put your Linux machine on the device that you want to use.
Exclusive for LQ members, get up to 45% off per month. Click here for more info.
Its sometimes essential to have NTFS and ext2 write support.
You doods and the ext2+ apps shouldnt care about whats exactly, they'd only recognize by some entry or the recovery journal.
ext3 is EXACTLY ext2, just with the additional journal that aint needed outside of unix, yet.
So i was using ext2fsd, running its setup on every boot to get me my r/o partitions.
I've tried but it didnt do much, it was copying an ext2.sys and stuff. After i ran the ext2fsd setup, it mounted my partitions r/w!
i probably will still have windoz-char-finding problems, for like the ipod.. it always overwrites F:, or at least tries to.. my linux partition wins in every case.
For those who wanna use my ext2fsd version, and download ext2fsnt.rar, both are on xmb.ath.cx
Hmm only every 10th directory has any content displayed by windoz.. now explorer is hung to 'my computer', rest work.
and everything accessing the fs, like winamp, but mp3's worked before, its still playing but i think its from another windoz share, winamp wont show up.
My conclusion to trying ext2fsd (v0.21) and ext2fsnt, both have kindof a setup script. if i run ext2fsnt first, then fsd, i get my mountes read-write, but much content in dirs inside are missing, tho you can make new directories and write to them w/o damage, for me at least.
If i run fsd first, i get the same read-only. newer fsd versions may do the job better, or other software.
Good day.
quote:Originally posted by joeljkp
Because if you have to use it, you want to be able to access your files on Linux, perhaps.
Then, put all your shared files in the FAT32 partition. Save EXT3 for the programs and kernel. Save NTFS for the programs and Windows system. All files shared between OSes should be in FAT32.
This is the best solution only if you have no need to share files over 4GB.
read the ext2fsd project page for this kind of info and the caveats of writing ext2/3 with windows using this driver.
Much of the performance will depend on how the windows and the linux systems are set up. However, word is that writing to ext from windows is not a problem.
i read the ext2fsd page before i got here, but only it says in general, its dangerous, its not supported, etc... but what i want to make clear is if, and not just with this driver, if i do write an ext3 mounted as ext2, and if the write was successful, then will i or have i caused damage to the ext3 partition, immediately or the next time its mounted as ext3?
If the designers cannot give you that assurance, nobody can.
Quote:
From the developer
Ext2fsd v0.22 is not strong yet in writing support, I recommend you create a little ext2 partition as a swap between winnt and linux or use bosse's filedisk to create an image file.
You can only try it and see.
For that matter, you could create a small vfat partition and use that with the windows fat32 driver... if you were worried.
but i mean, in principle, can it be done.
you must be misunderstanding my question.
If everything does go as it should, does writing a ext2 mounted ext3 partition damage it?
for instance, the next time that partition is mounted as ext3 will the journal be wrong?, could the files written as ext2 be missing?,even if the journal is wrong does it matter?
Ignoring the windows issue for a bit - imagen you have an older linux without ext3 support and for some reason you must manipulate a disk formatted with ext3 ... which will later be used in a machine which does have ext3 support.
ext3 is backwards compatable with ext2 - and can be mounted as ext2 on the old system. You can read and write files et al. Presumably the journal is not updated. If the system shuts down uncleanly - it will perform an ext2 fschk to attemt to correct any damage as normal.
Transfer to the ext3-enabled system ... and the files will all be there. The changes will not be in the journal... but you can touch all the files to get them written to the journal (I havn't done this so I'm extrapolating from the descriptions ... someone correct me if I get this wrong.) ... if your system should shut down uncleanly before you do this, then you will lose all the changes made from the last journal update when you reboot.
Remember, the journal is only needed when the system reboots after an unclean shutdown (your little brother threw the circuit breaker while you were playing the 23rd level on Iotot 5:"Revenge of the Fnords" ...)
Because if you have to use it, you want to be able to access your files on Linux, perhaps.
That's true, but sometimes you need it, ive been trying to get my 5 younger brothers and sisters to use linux, a ver friendly distro like ubuntu, but until now i failed. So they need the pc to do stuff, an i only use linux, specially because most tools i use are a lot better in linux, for example latex (by the way, there is finally a nice LaTeX editor in gtk "winefish" is very nice now), and ive downloaded some files that i need to use on the wondows partition, so i need to access my linux one, you see, i dont want this, but i cant help it.
Welcome to LQ.
This thread is almost half a decade old.
I know we prefer you to reply to existing threads but it is better to reply to newer posts - prefereabsy ones which have no existing replies.
LinuxQuestions.org is looking for people interested in writing
Editorials, Articles, Reviews, and more. If you'd like to contribute
content, let us know.