LinuxQuestions.org

LinuxQuestions.org (/questions/)
-   General (https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/general-10/)
-   -   If social media's bad then so is free speech? (https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/general-10/if-social-medias-bad-then-so-is-free-speech-4175701416/)

jamison20000e 10-03-2021 10:28 PM

I think frankbell hit it on the nose. Like, racist people may, or may not do, depending how stupid their parents or surroundings may have made us?! ;)

rkelsen 10-03-2021 10:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jbuckley2004 (Post 6288838)
I'm back on FB after years of ignoring them only to correspond to some old friends from ages gone past. But in both cases, no real alternative has appeared. In a society committed to free enterprise, alternatives would be apparent by now.

Are you kidding me? An internet search for "alternatives to facebook" yields 1.6 billion results.

This is one of the first ones: https://www.maketecheasier.com/faceb...cial-networks/
Quote:

Originally Posted by jbuckley2004 (Post 6288838)
The fact that they aren't tells us all that true competition is being effectively subverted. Some call that over regulation by g'ment bureaucrats. Some call it corruption.

I'd call it a customer base with tunnel vision.

There is no conspiracy. There is no over-regulation. Just a whole bunch of dumb people eating sh_t sandwiches.
Quote:

Originally Posted by jbuckley2004 (Post 6288838)
I say it's our willingness to put up with stuff like that.

Now you're getting closer to the mark.

jamison20000e 10-03-2021 11:01 PM

Logout of LQ n try using it...

Quite frankly: if people knew how to search and think for themselves, this site would be more useful? No offense ta small business men.

Both media and free speech, help people: not think for ourselves??? Or, are we just... enablers?

Forgotten what I was gonna say next? Smiley time!

scasey 10-04-2021 12:32 AM

The premise that social media is “bad” is not well supported, but has already been said, freedom of speech has nothing to do with social media in any case.
Quote:

Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…
The whole point of the first amendment is that Congress (the State) cannot control the press nor prevent anyone from saying what they want. Congress.

Ser Olmy 10-04-2021 07:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scasey (Post 6288870)
The whole point of the first amendment is that Congress (the State) cannot control the press nor prevent anyone from saying what they want. Congress.

If that is correct, why are demonstrators or protesters commonly given police protection to make sure their speech is not being silenced by others?

There are indeed to schools of thought here: Some believe Free Speech is a natural right and that the state exists partly to protect those rights, while others believe that rights only exist to the extent they are given to you by the state.

hazel 10-04-2021 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rkelsen (Post 6288794)
If you don't like Twitter or Facebook, there are other providers you can use.

Yes, there used to be Parler and it became rather popular among people who had been banned from Twitter. And what happened then? Amazon Web Services, which hosts just about everything on the net these days, decided that they would not host Parler and they kicked it off their servers.

So much for free speech and alternative channels.

rkelsen 10-04-2021 07:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hazel (Post 6288949)
Yes, there used to be Parler and it became rather popular among people who had been banned from Twitter. And what happened then? Amazon Web Services, which hosts just about everything on the net these days, decided that they would not host Parler and they kicked it off their servers.

So much for free speech and alternative channels.

Again, Amazon Web Services is a private business. Are you arguing that private business should be regulated in this regard???

hazel 10-04-2021 07:26 AM

Private businesses have always been regulated when they become monopolies because monopolies are against the public interest. Why are online monopolies different?

maw_walker 10-04-2021 07:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hazel (Post 6288949)
Yes, there used to be Parler and it became rather popular among people who had been banned from Twitter. And what happened then? Amazon Web Services, which hosts just about everything on the net these days, decided that they would not host Parler and they kicked it off their servers.

So much for free speech and alternative channels.

They did this because Parler hosted right-wing hate groups. Same reason Twitter banned right-wing hate speech. Freedom does not equal anarchy. That is one concept lost among some people; they feel they have the "right" to do and say anything because (speaking of the US), this is a "free" country.

As other have stated, these are private companies and they can do whatever they want. They should not be regulated by any government because then the government can inject its interests into the business. We already have far too much government intervention in private business here in the US.

Ser Olmy 10-04-2021 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rkelsen (Post 6288816)
Yeah. I take full responsibility for my own actions. If my conduct were to cause me to be banned from all of those, then I probably deserved it.

OK, as long as you recognize that according to the powers that be, you do deserve it. As in, right now.

The only reason you haven't experienced their ire is that you're neither in the public eye, nor in a position to inconvenience those disagreeing with your opinions. That can change in an instant.

If the "right" to voice your opinion means that if you do so you get fired, evicted, expelled from college or university, lose your bank account and credit card, and find yourself unable to shop or participate in any public discourse online, then the entire "right" is fictional.

Ser Olmy 10-04-2021 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maw_walker (Post 6288957)
They did this because Parler hosted right-wing hate groups.

That's been investigated and debunked by the FBI.

They did find some questionable online activity by some individuals. On Facebook.

Parler hosted people Twitter claimed were all sorts of things. That's not the same as them actually being any of those things. And of course they were on Parler, Twitter had just thrown them out.

Ser Olmy 10-04-2021 07:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hazel (Post 6288956)
Private businesses have always been regulated when they become monopolies because monopolies are against the public interest. Why are online monopolies different?

Because they're willing to act as the extended arm of certain political groups. Also, they make political contributions.

cynwulf 10-04-2021 12:05 PM

They are mostly public companies. Finding those with overall control as well as those with major stakes can be an entertaining paper trail.

Don't worry about governments interfering in these corporations....

Worry about the level of influence and control they already have over governments... not just yours... as they include some of the major political donors - to the parties which have pledged to best serve their interests - not yours.

jamison20000e 10-04-2021 02:36 PM

Everyones heard, sticks and stones may break their bones? I've always liked to say: if I can't say anything and get away with it, you're a moron? But,,, only a smart @#$ minus the smarts whould say that. :p

Hackers and anarchists are not same, except stereotyped?

Democracy seems a giant corporation? You (I say you because I've never voted for persons, only policies. Which should be mandatory and never taken away!) try to find people aligned with your views and hope they don't change? CEO Biden*... 🙄

https://www.gnu.org/software/social/
https://medevel.com/open-source-solu...ocial-network/

I think if we ever get to the point where we can say anything and get away with it? We won't be staying stupid 💩

GentleThotSeaMonkey 10-04-2021 03:30 PM

FB/IG/WA gonzo. Did Zuck del all his BGP&DNS? (after 60minutes show)
 
https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/co...down/?sort=new
(EDIT: that got locked. From 'legit': https://blog.cloudflare.com/october-...acebook-outage
Edit#2: (UNfortunately) it's back (BGP 'fixed') https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28752131

I'm looking forward to reading: How to delete *ALL* BGP&DNS info about a company. (new kali cmd?)
("deleting all BGP routing &DNS info" 'disappears' them from internet)

I'd love to be the fly on Zuckerberg's head right now.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:15 PM.