LinuxQuestions.org
Visit Jeremy's Blog.
Go Back   LinuxQuestions.org > Forums > Non-*NIX Forums > General
User Name
Password
General This forum is for non-technical general discussion which can include both Linux and non-Linux topics. Have fun!

Notices

Reply
 
Search this Thread
Old 12-30-2012, 06:41 AM   #1
Mr. Alex
Senior Member
 
Registered: May 2010
Distribution: Arch + X.org + IceWM
Posts: 1,204

Rep: Reputation: Disabled
Post Why is US style of punctuation with quotation marks this way?


Hi all! I was searching info on this subject - commas and periods inside or outside of quotation marks and everything seems to say pretty much the same except one forum post somewhere where an OP was referring to some source explaining why US style of punctuation places commas and periods inside quotes like:

Quote:
"Use 'tar' with 'xz' for better compression," said John.
instead of

Quote:
"Use 'tar' with 'xz' for better compression", said John.
I thought to digg into it later and now I can't find that page.

Does anyone know the reason of placing commas inside?
 
Old 12-30-2012, 07:10 AM   #2
brianL
LQ 5k Club
 
Registered: Jan 2006
Location: Oldham, Lancs, England
Distribution: Slackware & Slackware64 14.1
Posts: 7,076
Blog Entries: 52

Rep: Reputation: Disabled
I don't know why they do it, but the Americans are wrong again - as usual.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 07:51 AM   #3
cascade9
Senior Member
 
Registered: Mar 2011
Location: Brisneyland
Distribution: Debian, aptosid
Posts: 3,718

Rep: Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904Reputation: 904
Maybe this was the page you were looking at?

http://grammartips.homestead.com/inside.html

Though I'm sure I've seen a better explanation with more little bits and pieces like 'semicolons and colons always go outside the quotation marks', stuffed if I can find it now.

Yet another example of how rules made to simplify things (like the US style 'punctuation inside quotation marks') can be stupid, and having a more flexible approach is better IMO. Then again, the world is full of stupid people....
 
Old 12-30-2012, 07:52 AM   #4
Thad E Ginataom
Member
 
Registered: Mar 2011
Distribution: Ubuntu 12.04 with KXStudio, MATE & Compiz
Posts: 46

Rep: Reputation: 7
I think this is a very easy mistake to make with English, and does not depend on which side of the Atlantic one grew up on. I think I make it too sometimes. So far as my side (UK) is concerned, English grammar has been a bit anything-goes for past several decades, but inside the quotes is "correct." <---which in this example, seems to me to be counter-intuitive!
 
Old 12-30-2012, 08:09 AM   #5
273
Senior Member
 
Registered: Dec 2011
Location: UK
Distribution: Debian Sid AMD64, Raspbian Wheezy, various VMs
Posts: 3,508

Rep: Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800
I put the punctuation where it makes sense so, for example:
The man shouted "Hey, you!" at John.
Jeremy said "I don't like fish.", apparently. [if that's all he said]
or
Jeremy said "I don't like fish ...", apparently. [if he went on to say more]
In other words I only quote what was said, as if it were a string literal. This may not be strictly correct but I'd rather be logically correct then follow some arbitrary rule.
Grammar rules change all the time and are often only there because of somebody's affectation (spelling is like this also with "color" and "colour", for example). As long as you're not publishing what you type then it ought not to matter, provided you make your meaning clear, and in that case you would have house guidelines to tell you what to do.

Last edited by 273; 12-30-2012 at 08:11 AM.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:13 AM   #6
Mr. Alex
Senior Member
 
Registered: May 2010
Distribution: Arch + X.org + IceWM
Posts: 1,204

Original Poster
Rep: Reputation: Disabled
Quote:
Originally Posted by cascade9 View Post
Maybe this was the page you were looking at?

http://grammartips.homestead.com/inside.html
Defenitely not. The source I'm talking about was saying something about times of mechanical typewriters or something like this... My bad I haven't focused my attention on it.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 11:23 AM   #7
jefro
Guru
 
Registered: Mar 2008
Posts: 11,954

Rep: Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482Reputation: 1482
We drive on the right side of the road.

Your search for answers would be more well suited to an American English web site. Opps, that was a poorly written sentence.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 11:45 AM   #8
Thad E Ginataom
Member
 
Registered: Mar 2011
Distribution: Ubuntu 12.04 with KXStudio, MATE & Compiz
Posts: 46

Rep: Reputation: 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Alex View Post
Defenitely not. The source I'm talking about was saying something about times of mechanical typewriters or something like this...
There's a fragment at the bottom which claims that commas inside the quotes goes back to a matter of hand typesetting. I can't say for sure, but it doesn't sound likely to me. I never set type by hand myself, but I've worked for a publisher/printer that had a letterpress department, and we did hand setting and I worked a lot with the printers and typesetters. I used to do layout for order forms, with multiple columns of |......1226/X123......| and we never lost any of those periods, which are just as small as a comma.

(Then we got a phototypesetter, and I learned how to photo-typeset them, which was my first contact with anything actually "computerised," and the precursor to my being given a Unix system to find out how to manage. But that's another story . The chief hand typesetter got to learn the photo-typesetting, but, sadly, I didn't get to learn his craft.)
 
Old 12-30-2012, 12:15 PM   #9
Mr. Alex
Senior Member
 
Registered: May 2010
Distribution: Arch + X.org + IceWM
Posts: 1,204

Original Poster
Rep: Reputation: Disabled
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thad E Ginataom View Post
There's a fragment at the bottom which claims that commas inside the quotes goes back to a matter of hand typesetting.
The one I'm talking about is a forum thread with discussion.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:11 PM   #10
frankbell
Guru
 
Registered: Jan 2006
Location: Virginia, USA
Distribution: Slackware, Mageia, Mint
Posts: 8,084

Rep: Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533
Traditionally, commas and periods have been placed inside quotation marks because it looks better in typewritten or handwritten copy; there is no other reason.

As far as I am concerned, it looks better in variable-spaced fonts too, though I know that the UK Guardian disagrees with me.

They are allowed to be wrong.

Large punctuation marks, such as question marks and exclamation points, are placed inside quotation marks only if they are part of the quotation. One ending punctuation mark per sentence suffices.

Compare, for example,

Quote:
He said, "Get lost!"

I could not believe he said, "Get lost"!

He asked, "What time is it?"

Did he ask, "What time is it"?

Last edited by frankbell; 12-30-2012 at 10:15 PM.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:25 PM   #11
k3lt01
Senior Member
 
Registered: Feb 2011
Location: Australia
Distribution: Debian Wheezy, Jessie, Sid/Experimental, playing with LFS.
Posts: 2,850

Rep: Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616
273 has it correct. When placing the , inside the quotation marks it indicates there is more to the sentence but that what is within the marks is all that was quoted.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:28 PM   #12
273
Senior Member
 
Registered: Dec 2011
Location: UK
Distribution: Debian Sid AMD64, Raspbian Wheezy, various VMs
Posts: 3,508

Rep: Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800Reputation: 800
As I tried to say, badly, I tend to use quotes as I would quote tags or quotes in C/C++/whatever and quote what I wish to. If "grammar" dictates that I'm wrong to do so it's obviously flawed and ought to be ignored.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:33 PM   #13
frankbell
Guru
 
Registered: Jan 2006
Location: Virginia, USA
Distribution: Slackware, Mageia, Mint
Posts: 8,084

Rep: Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533Reputation: 1533
Quote:
Originally Posted by k3lt01 View Post
273 has it correct. When placing the , inside the quotation marks it indicates there is more to the sentence but that what is within the marks is all that was quoted.
In the States, we would use elipses to indicate that a portion was omitted from a quotation:

Quote:
The politician said, "I cannot take a position on that issue."

The politician said, "I cannot take a position . . . ."
Frankly, I do not believe and have never read or been taught (and I've read extensively on grammar and syntax, having made my living with my pen most of my career) that the position of the comma is adequate to convey anything to a casual reader. If that is how it is interpreted in the Commonwealth, the secret is deeply held.
 
Old 12-30-2012, 10:57 PM   #14
odiseo77
Senior Member
 
Registered: Dec 2004
Location: London, UK
Distribution: Debian Sid, OpenSUSE 13.1
Posts: 1,016

Rep: Reputation: 308Reputation: 308Reputation: 308Reputation: 308
I thought placing the periods and the commas inside the quotation marks was the rule for English in general (not only US English). BTW, I find it awkward and unnatural unless it's an exclamation/question sign that is part of the phrase you're quoting (as in frankbell's example above).

So, if someone ends a paragraph in an academic paper with some author's quote, do they have to put the full stop period inside the quotation marks? It would look weird to me
 
Old 12-31-2012, 02:45 AM   #15
k3lt01
Senior Member
 
Registered: Feb 2011
Location: Australia
Distribution: Debian Wheezy, Jessie, Sid/Experimental, playing with LFS.
Posts: 2,850

Rep: Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616Reputation: 616
Quote:
Originally Posted by frankbell View Post
In the States, we would use elipses to indicate that a portion was omitted from a quotation:
The use of elipses is used if there is no other break.

Quote:
Originally Posted by frankbell View Post
Frankly, I do not believe and have never read or been taught (and I've read extensively on grammar and syntax, having made my living with my pen most of my career) that the position of the comma is adequate to convey anything to a casual reader. If that is how it is interpreted in the Commonwealth, the secret is deeply held.
Punctuation is important, it breaks sentences and/or paragraphs into smaller portions. Whether a casual reader knowingly understands this or not is neither here nor there. I have seen enough posts in LQ telling people to format their posts differently so they can be more easily understood to think casual readers do actually understand the need for punctuation.
 
  


Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
[SOLVED] how to use quotation marks in c++ stream knobby67 Programming 3 07-28-2011 03:07 AM
can not input double quotation marks(invalid quotation key) wangzhilife Linux - Hardware 2 09-18-2009 07:44 AM
missing em dash & other punctuation marks in font warnerwhite Linux - Newbie 0 01-28-2009 02:01 PM
Use of quotation marks in bash dunryc Programming 2 06-08-2008 03:24 PM
no quotation marks jdoe9898 Linux - Newbie 1 10-12-2005 04:07 AM


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:11 PM.

Main Menu
My LQ
Write for LQ
LinuxQuestions.org is looking for people interested in writing Editorials, Articles, Reviews, and more. If you'd like to contribute content, let us know.
Main Menu
Syndicate
RSS1  Latest Threads
RSS1  LQ News
Twitter: @linuxquestions
identi.ca: @linuxquestions
Facebook: linuxquestions Google+: linuxquestions
Open Source Consulting | Domain Registration