If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?
GeneralThis forum is for non-technical general discussion which can include both Linux and non-Linux topics. Have fun!
Welcome to LinuxQuestions.org, a friendly and active Linux Community.
You are currently viewing LQ as a guest. By joining our community you will have the ability to post topics, receive our newsletter, use the advanced search, subscribe to threads and access many other special features. Registration is quick, simple and absolutely free. Join our community today!
Note that registered members see fewer ads, and ContentLink is completely disabled once you log in.
The evolution of species does not occur in large steps, but rather in very small changes over centuries. To be sure, there can be large mutations which result in life-forms that go extinct very quickly. Normal evolution, however, is a series a very subtle changes which might never be noticed in the lifetime of the average observer.
By this logic, the chicken slowly evolved from something maybe larger, slower, less intelligent, etc. In this process, what we know now as a chicken was "selected" because its unique evolutionary path favored the environment.
On a macro scale, the emergence (and evolution) of life was from single-celled (simple) life-forms to ones much more complex. The egg is a simpler life-form than a chicken---therefore the egg came first.
Just a more elaborate way of saying the same. The two questions are actually related. Because of the way we have defined words like 'Chicken' and 'sound'. At some point of the evolution of chickens we have put a line. Before which we would have called the bird something else. Then the necessary evolution/mutation happened and a new chicken would have been something else than both its parents, so the egg was first (as at least pixellany and I agree). Actually the reputable BBC agree too:
On sound and trees falling. Check this definition in Wiktionary:
A sensation perceived by the ear caused by the vibration of air or some other medium. (He turned when he heard the sound of footsteps behind him.)
Nobody made a sound.
On this definition, if there is no-one there to hear the falling tree, there is no sound.
Maybe Linux people are more evolved than others and that's why philosophical things appear here
Now that I think of it, and being more serious, there is such a thing as psychological deafness, something I suspect my grandmother has. Her hearing is perfectly fine, but she doesn't hear important things, for example an ambulance (with sirens and lights on) almost ran her down, and damn those things are noisy, but she never heard it coming. This is explained due to the fact that her brain was ignoring signals from he ears at the time (a bad decision). However, she often manages to hear things said in whisper tone, things she wasn't supposed to hear ... had a number of negative experiences with this ... don't assume she can't hear you, she can if she wants to.
We're up to four pages on this stupid post. Can someone please explain why my meaningful posts with relevant issues are generally ignored, while useless posts like this take off to multiple pages????
Here goes completely unnecessary answer:
Because technical problems ("meaningful posts", as I suppose) are all solved in same way (search google, read manual, read code, ask for help, give up), and solution for those haven't much room for creativity/fun. It is just finding facts and presenting them to the people. Even google-fu becomes boring after a while. Also when polite people don't know answer, they don't provide useless information, so that's why posts are "ignored". Also if questions is too simple (basic, OP "didn't do his homework"), many people won't post answer (because they'll think OP is too lazy).
Meaningless posts are fun, because there is space for creativity - it's like (unofficial) competition where everyone tries to make as much fun as possible from initial statement, tries to invent new joke, etc.
I.e. presenting facts is boring unless you feel generous and like playing role of tech support for a while. Mockery of "meaningless posts" is fun because you might have a laugh in process, and you might invent new joke, etc. The exception from this are unique technical problem, that are rare and require a lot of thinking. In this case you get satisfaction when you finally solve problem.
Yes, the unfortunate squirrel sat in the silently falling tree. The chicken, having no ears, made sound disappear. Similar to H_TeXMeX_H's grandmother making sound of sirens disappear.
Luckily the chicken had seen the tree and crossed the road to avoid it.
Poor squirrel sat in the tree. Not sure what happened to it.
Distribution: Slack, Solaris, whatever I have space for
Originally Posted by ErV
Here goes completely unnecessary answer:
Because technical problems ("meaningful posts", as I suppose) are all solved in same way (search google, read manual, read code, ask for help, give up), and solution for those haven't much room for creativity/fun.
Despite your credible explanation, I must disagree, and assert that the same type of question could also be applied to system administration. For example,
If Windows crashes, and no one hears my scream of anguish, did I make a sound?
In space you would not have a chance to scream because you would already have exploded into little chunks before you could scream.
Nice chunks to be fed to mr Schroedinger's cat together with the dead squirrel. This is the cat that is both alive and dead at the same time. The alive one needs to be able to stay alive and not die as well. Quantum physics would be even more bizarre if it did...